By Rose Kearney-Nunnery,RN, PhD Back | Next Interactive Exercises Home Student Resource Home
Interactive ExercisesChapter 06, Exercise 02:Development of an Objective Critique of Research
Critique a nursing research article that pertains to your clinical practice area and develop an objective critique of the study using the format below.
Reference citation
What is the applicability to practice?
Introduction
Problem
Purpose
Identify the main issues, their significance to nursing and to clients as well as the aims of the study.
Literature Review
Identify the background, sources, viariables, primary sources, criticall analysis, strengths, weaaknessess.
Theoretical Framework
Description, citations, type, guidance
Research questions or hypotheses
Clarity, appropriateness, consistency with framework, variables
Methods
Design
Identify, describe, variables, controls
Ethics
Protections
Sampling
Method, appropriateness, characteristics, generalizability, representativeness
Data Collection
Methods, instruments, reliability, validity
Results and Analysis
Methods, appropriateness, statistics, answers to the research questions and/or results for hypotheses, appropriate statistics, figures/tables
Discussion
Conclusions, consistent and support for theory, based on the data, limitations, generalizations
Recommendations
Practice, teaching, administration, research
Discuss the applicability of this research to your practice setting and the potential for using the findings.